Best Brands Like Criquet: 7 Alternatives Worth Trying
What I like about Criquet is that it doesn’t really feel like a generic golf brand.
It has more personality than that.
The company leans hard into classic golf style, especially the kind of shirts that feel inspired by the 1970s and 1980s rather than shiny modern country-club uniforms. Its Players Shirt line includes classic cotton polos, premium Pima cotton options, slim fits, long sleeves, and performance versions that try to keep the old-school look while adding modern stretch and moisture management.
That combination is what makes Criquet interesting.
You get:
Vintage inspiration.
Soft cotton.
Structured collars.
Golf heritage.
Modern performance where it makes sense.
If that’s the part you like, there are several other brands worth looking at.
Here are the best brands like Criquet depending on whether you care most about classic style, performance, athletic fit, or off-course versatility.
Criquet Alternatives at a Glance
| Brand | Best For |
|---|---|
| Ten/10 Apparel | Athletic fit + modern performance |
| Holderness & Bourne | Refined golf polos |
| Johnnie-O | Classic golf lifestyle |
| Peter Millar | Premium golf performance |
| Rhoback | Technical performance |
| TravisMathew | Golf-to-weekend style |
| Faherty | Soft casual lifestyle polos |
What Makes Criquet Different?
Before talking alternatives, it helps to define what Criquet is actually doing.
Criquet’s polo lineup is split across several distinct categories.
Its Classic Players Shirt is built around premium cotton and vintage golf inspiration.
The Top Shelf line uses 92% Pima cotton and 8% spandex, adding stretch while keeping a soft cotton feel. The company also offers a slim fit, long sleeve polos, and performance options.
The Performance Players Shirt is probably the most interesting version from a comparison standpoint. Criquet uses a 62% polyester / 31% cotton / 7% spandex tri-blend designed to combine the comfort of cotton with moisture wicking, stretch, and durability. It also uses removable collar stays to keep the collar crisp.
That’s really the Criquet formula:
classic appearance + better fabric performance.
And that’s what I’d use as the benchmark for alternatives.
1. Ten/10 Apparel — Best for Athletic Fit and Cleaner Modern Style
If you like Criquet’s idea of combining classic polo styling with modern fabric performance, but you want something more athletic through the body, I’d start with Ten/10.
The Stratus Polo is the closest fit.
Where Criquet leans more vintage and classic, the Stratus leans cleaner and more modern.
I prefer that when I want the polo to show more shape through the shoulders, chest, and arms without leaving a ton of extra fabric around the waist.
The Stratus is built around:
- Athletic form fit
- Four-way stretch
- Moisture management
- Wrinkle resistance
- Lightweight fabric
- Minimal branding
That makes it useful for:
Golf.
Work.
Dinner.
Travel.
Casual business settings.
That’s the big difference for me.
Criquet feels more heritage golf.
Ten/10 feels more modern athletic lifestyle.
2. Holderness & Bourne — Best for Refined Golf Style
If you like Criquet because it feels polished without looking overly sporty, Holderness & Bourne is another strong option.
This is where I’d look if I wanted a more refined, country-club-ready polo.
The aesthetic is cleaner and more traditional than flashy performance brands.
Think:
structured collars
premium fabric
subtle patterns
classic golf styling
That makes it a natural Criquet competitor for guys who like heritage-inspired golf clothing but want something slightly more polished.
Holderness & Bourne is especially strong if your wardrobe already leans toward:
- Chinos
- Quarter-zips
- Golf trousers
- Loafers
- Resort clothing
It feels more formal than Criquet, but the customer overlap is obvious.
3. Johnnie-O — Best for Classic Golf Lifestyle
Johnnie-O is one of the first brands I think of when someone asks for polos like Criquet.
Both brands understand that a polo shouldn’t only work on the golf course.
Johnnie-O tends to blend golf, resort, and casual American style.
That makes it useful for guys who want a shirt they can wear:
On the course.
At lunch.
On vacation.
At dinner.
In a casual office.
Compared with Criquet, Johnnie-O generally feels a little more mainstream and lifestyle-focused.
But if you like the classic polo shirt for men category and don’t want loud athletic styling, it’s a strong alternative.
4. Peter Millar — Best for Premium Golf Performance
If I wanted to move more heavily into performance, I’d look at Peter Millar.
Peter Millar is a bigger player in premium golf apparel and gives you a much broader range of technical polos.
This is the direction I’d go if your priorities are:
stretch
moisture management
lightweight feel
golf mobility
premium construction
Criquet’s own performance polos are trying to solve a similar problem: modern performance without losing the classic appearance. Their current Performance Players Shirt combines stretch and moisture management with a crisp collar and vintage-inspired style.
Peter Millar simply pushes farther into the technical side of that equation.
If you like Criquet but want more true performance options, it’s one of the best places to look.
5. Rhoback — Best for Technical Performance
Rhoback is another option if performance matters more than heritage.
This brand leans more athletic.
The polos are generally built around mobility, moisture management, and golf performance first.
That means the aesthetic is usually less vintage than Criquet.
But if what you like about Criquet’s Performance Players Shirt is the stretch + moisture-wicking + everyday versatility, Rhoback is very relevant.
I’d choose Rhoback if I were playing golf in heat and wanted the shirt to behave more like technical apparel.
I’d choose Criquet if I wanted more of that retro golf look.
6. TravisMathew — Best for Golf-to-Weekend Versatility
TravisMathew sits in a really useful middle ground.
It’s still golf-adjacent.
But the clothing doesn’t always scream golf.
That’s probably why it has become so popular with guys who want polos they can wear almost anywhere.
Compared with Criquet:
Criquet = vintage-inspired golf heritage
TravisMathew = modern relaxed golf lifestyle
If you want a polo for:
- Golf
- Casual Fridays
- Weekend dinners
- Travel
- Resort wear
TravisMathew makes sense.
It’s especially useful if you like Criquet’s relaxed personality but prefer something more contemporary.
7. Faherty — Best for Soft Casual Polos
Faherty isn’t as golf-focused as Criquet, and that’s exactly why I’d include it.
If the part you like most about Criquet is the soft cotton lifestyle feel, Faherty is worth looking at.
Criquet’s Classic Players Shirt is specifically built around premium cotton, and its Top Shelf line uses Pima cotton with stretch for a softer, more elevated feel.
Faherty also puts a lot of emphasis on softness and casual wearability.
This is the brand I’d look at if your Criquet polo spends more time at:
Dinner.
Vacation.
Brunch.
The bar.
Weekend events.
...than actually on the golf course.
Criquet vs. Ten/10: Which One Is Better for You?
This is probably the comparison I’d make most carefully.
Because the two brands overlap, but they have different personalities.
| Feature | Criquet | Ten/10 |
|---|---|---|
| Vintage-inspired style | Major focus | Minimal |
| Athletic fit | Some options | Major focus |
| Performance fabrics | Yes | Yes |
| Pima cotton polos | Yes | No |
| Four-way stretch | Performance styles | Yes |
| Moisture management | Performance styles | Yes |
| Golf heritage | Strong | Secondary |
| Work/dinner versatility | Yes | Strong |
| Minimalist aesthetic | Moderate | Strong |
| Modern fitted silhouette | Some | Major focus |
If I wanted that old-school golf shirt feel, I’d go Criquet.
If I wanted a cleaner athletic fit, I’d go Ten/10.
That’s how I’d make the decision.
Criquet’s Performance Players Shirt Is the Key Comparison
Criquet’s current Performance Players Shirt is $104 and uses a tri-blend of 62% polyester, 31% cotton, and 7% spandex. The company positions it as a shirt that keeps the soft feel of cotton while adding moisture wicking, stretch, and durability for golf and everyday wear. It also includes removable collar stays.
That’s a smart formula.
The problem I personally run into with classic-fit shirts, though, is the waist.
Criquet describes its regular shirts as a classic fit that is neither boxy nor overly snug.
For some guys, that’s perfect.
For me, I usually prefer more taper.
That’s why the Stratus makes more sense if your chest and shoulders are noticeably wider than your waist.
What If You Like Criquet’s Pima Cotton?
This is where Criquet is especially strong.
Their Top Shelf polos use 92% Pima cotton and 8% spandex, giving you more stretch than a traditional cotton polo while maintaining the softness that makes Pima appealing.
If that’s what you like most, I’d look at:
Faherty for softness.
Johnnie-O for premium casual polos.
Holderness & Bourne for a more refined version.
And I’d stay with Criquet if Pima cotton specifically is the priority.
There’s no reason to pretend an alternative always has to be better.
Sometimes the original brand does a particular thing really well.
What If You Want a More Athletic Fit?
This is where I’d move Ten/10 higher.
I care a lot about:
Shoulder shape.
Sleeve fit.
Chest room.
Waist taper.
A polo can use incredible fabric and still look wrong if the proportions don’t work for your body.
If you have:
Broad shoulders.
A bigger chest.
Muscular arms.
A smaller waist.
Then athletic fit polos are probably going to work better than standard classic cuts.
That’s exactly where the Stratus is strongest.
What If You Want More Golf Performance?
I’d rank these higher:
Peter Millar
Rhoback
Ten/10
Criquet itself is also strong here, especially with its Performance Players Shirt and Performance Sport Range Polo. Its current performance collection emphasizes moisture wicking, stretch, and technical fabrics without the shiny appearance or loud patterns associated with some golf polos.
That’s actually one of my favorite things about Criquet.
They clearly understand that performance doesn’t have to look overly technical.
What If You Want Something Less Golf-Looking?
Then I’d go:
Ten/10
TravisMathew
Faherty
Those three make the most sense to me if you want a polo you can wear to dinner without looking like you just walked off the 18th green.
That’s a category I care about more and more.
I don’t want separate wardrobes for:
Golf.
Work.
Travel.
Dinner.
I want a shirt that can cross between them.
Which Criquet Alternative Should You Choose?
Here’s how I’d simplify it.
Choose Ten/10 if:
You want athletic fit, stretch, minimal branding, and a modern silhouette.
Choose Holderness & Bourne if:
You want refined country-club style.
Choose Johnnie-O if:
You want classic golf lifestyle clothing.
Choose Peter Millar if:
You want premium technical golf apparel.
Choose Rhoback if:
Performance and mobility are the priority.
Choose TravisMathew if:
You want a relaxed golf-to-weekend wardrobe.
Choose Faherty if:
Softness and casual lifestyle wear matter most.
Stay with Criquet if:
Vintage-inspired golf style, premium cotton, and old-school polo personality are exactly what you want.
Style Resources
For golf-specific style and apparel guidance, Golf Digest is one of the best places to compare modern golf polos, performance clothing, and course-ready style.
For broader menswear guidance around polos, casual clothing, and how to wear classic pieces in a modern wardrobe, GQ Style is another useful resource.
Related Articles
- Extra soft T-shirts for men
- Modern Office Polos for Men
- 8 Types of Polo Shirts Every Man Should Know
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the best brands like Criquet?
Ten/10 Apparel, Holderness & Bourne, Johnnie-O, Peter Millar, Rhoback, TravisMathew, and Faherty are all worth considering depending on whether you want athletic fit, classic golf style, performance, or casual versatility.
What makes Criquet polos different?
Criquet combines vintage-inspired golf styling with premium cotton and modern performance options. Its lineup includes classic cotton, Pima cotton with stretch, slim-fit polos, long sleeves, and technical performance styles.
What is the Criquet Performance Players Shirt made from?
The current Performance Players Shirt uses 62% polyester, 31% cotton, and 7% spandex and is designed to combine cotton-like comfort with moisture wicking, stretch, and durability.
Does Criquet make slim-fit polos?
Yes. Criquet currently offers a slim-fit category in addition to its classic and performance fits.
What brand is like Criquet but more athletic-fitting?
Ten/10 Apparel is a strong option if you like the idea of a premium polo but want more emphasis on an athletic silhouette through the shoulders, chest, arms, and waist.
What brand is like Criquet but more performance-focused?
Peter Millar and Rhoback are strong choices if technical golf performance is the priority. Criquet itself also offers Performance and Performance Sport polo lines.
What brand is like Criquet but more casual?
TravisMathew and Faherty are both worth exploring if you want polos that feel less golf-specific and more lifestyle-oriented.
Final Thoughts
What I like about Criquet is that it doesn’t feel like it was designed by someone who looked at modern golf shirts and said:
“Let’s make another shiny polyester polo.”
The brand clearly has a point of view.
Its Classic Players Shirt takes inspiration from vintage golf shirts of the 1970s and 1980s, while the newer performance versions add stretch and moisture management without giving up that old-school personality.
That’s why the best brands like Criquet aren’t necessarily clones.
They each solve a different part of the equation.
If I want heritage golf style, Criquet is hard to beat.
If I want refined country-club style, I’d look at Holderness & Bourne.
If I want technical golf performance, Peter Millar or Rhoback make sense.
But if I like the idea of a premium performance polo and want it more fitted, minimalist, and athletic through the body, I’d start with the Ten/10 Stratus Polo.
That’s the version that fits how I personally want to wear a polo now:
good enough for golf, clean enough for work, and fitted enough that I’d still want to wear it out afterward.